SVD with different solution as WolframAlpha

asked 2014-05-07 06:16:26 -0600

glethien gravatar image

I've found out that the results of the SVDecomp function in Java are very different from the results of WolframAlpha.

The input matrix is excactly the same for OpenCV and WolframAlpha

{{0.2229632566816983, 18.15370964847313, 4.87085706173828},
{-14.31728552253419, 2.642676839378287, -33.69501515553716},
{-2.982323803144884, 33.70091859922499, 0.8997452211463326}}

Here are the results from WolframAlpha:

U = (-0.441818862735368 | 0.214800119324567 | -0.871009185525260
-0.245069575462508 | -0.962880608842737 | -0.113145200062862
-0.862981457340684 | 0.163468167704881 | 0.478059789601005)
W = (38.5925763913943 | 0 | 0
0 | 36.8337256561100 | 0
0 | 0 | 3.76859638821616×10^-10)
V = (0.155053443270976 | 0.362336795687042 | 0.919059560758203
-0.978207790691182 | 0.186347267503429 | 0.0915653543928191
0.138086740713550 | 0.913228745925823 | -0.383334461865688)

And here is what OpenCV produces when using SCDecomp:

 U: [0.4418188627353685, 0.2148001193245664, -0.8710091855252606;
0.2450695754625076, -0.9628806088427376, -0.113145200062862;
 0.8629814573406845, 0.1634681677048805, 0.4780597896010051]
 W: [38.59257639139431; 36.83372565611004; 3.768597946996713e-10]
 VT:[-0.155053443270976, 0.3623367956870423, 0.9190595607582029;
 0.9782077906911818, 0.1863472675034285, 0.09156535439281914;
-0.1380867407135498, 0.9132287459258235, -0.3833344618656882]

To mention: W in OpenCV is not a matrix, as well as the sign of the values are sometimes different.

Is this a bug? Here is my SourceCode

Core.SVDecomp(E, w, u, vt);
edit retag flag offensive close merge delete

Comments

Hi, I have the same issue.. Did you find any solution to that? thanks

Isam gravatar imageIsam ( 2016-12-28 00:41:50 -0600 )edit